Skip to main content

Plausible Deniability


It happened, much to their dismay, just as he said it would.

The event and everything preceding it rocked their world.  In their desperation, they had to make it all disappear or at least invalidate it.  The best that they could do was to argue that his friends did it.  They came and stole it.

But they also had to deal with the guys who supposedly allowed his friends to come and steal it.  These guys were supposed to guard it.  And they were not your run of the mill rent-a-cops.  They were seasoned professionals.

So they convinced the commanding officers over the guys to say that they just fell asleep on the job.  Then his friends came and stole it.  But there was a problem with that story.  They either forgot or overlooked or simply chose to ignore it in their desperation to create a narrative.  The problem was that those who fell asleep would normally be put to death for dereliction of duty.

But, they pressed ahead with the narrative.  We’ll back up your story they told the commanding officers, as they handed over the bribe.  It was designed to create, as we call it today, plausible deniability.

Plausible deniability can refer to a lack of evidence proving an allegation and if the allegation cannot be proved, one can plausibly deny the allegation even though it may be true.

But, the narrative ended up unraveling as the evidence mounted.  If his friends had stolen it (the “it” being his body), then how could they explain this account?

While they were still talking about this, Jesus himself stood among them and said to them, “Peace be with you.”  They were startled and frightened, thinking they saw a ghost. He said to them, “Why are you troubled, and why do doubts rise in your minds?  Look at my hands and my feet. It is I myself! Touch me and see; a ghost does not have flesh and bones, as you see I have.”  When he had said this, he showed them his hands and feet. And while they still did not believe it because of joy and amazement, he asked them, “Do you have anything here to eat?”  They gave him a piece of broiled fish, and he took it and ate it in their presence.  (Luke 24:36-43)

 The narrative fell apart.  Plausible deniability didn’t work.  The real story is that it all happened just as he said it would:  “This is what is written: The Messiah will suffer and rise from the dead on the third day”.  (Luke 24:46)

 His body wasn’t stolen!  He rose from the dead, just as he said!


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

New Year Trash or Treasure?

You probably know the old saying:  “One man’s trash is another man’s treasure”.  I am not going to try to prove or disprove it, just look at it from a different angle. Cheryl and I were recently walking on a beach in Florida .  A man was walking along with a bag and was picking up trash and putting it in the bag.  Was he picking up things of value? We also saw a different man walking along the same beach with a metal detector.  He would swing it back and forth and would occasionally stop and dig in the sand.  Was he looking for things of value? Both were intent.  Both were focused.  Both were diligent. I’m guessing that the one picking up trash was not looking for things of value.  I’m also guessing that, by picking up trash, he was valuing the beauty of the beach and didn’t want the trash to mar it.  The one with the metal detector, I’m guessing that he was not looking for metallic items of trash but was looking for...
1 comment
Read more

Don't Get Tripped Up

I do enjoy traveling and I keep an eye out for good prices. I also enjoy looking at trends in travel. For a while, the travel industry focused their advertising on taking those trips that might be on your bucket list.   That faded a bit and I started seeing ads about taking the trip of a lifetime. I guess both those campaigns have been waning since I’ve been seeing information about taking an “epic” trip.   Recently I noticed the phrase “unforgettable trip” in advertising.   More recently, I’ve been seeing promotions about taking “sustainable” trips and even “reconnecting to our roots” trips. As I’ve been pondering these advertising campaigns, I thought I’d consider what their ideas encompass and then look at them from a spiritual perspective: 1.   “ Bucket list trips ” are based on a list of the experiences a person might hope to have before they “kick the bucket” (i.e. die).   While I can certainly come up with a bucket list of trips, I’m thinking a bu...
Post a Comment
Read more

Above My Pay Grade!

We like things that we can study, know and understand.  Sometimes we find it difficult to accept that there are things that might be hidden from our knowledge and understanding. The Scriptures indicate that there are some things hidden by design:  “The Lord our God keeps certain things hidden. But he makes other things known to us and to our children forever. He does it so we can obey all the words of this law.”  (Deut 29:29) Some versions of the Bible translate the hidden things as “secret things”.  Regardless, there are things which have been revealed and things which are kept hidden from us and remain secret. We may chafe at having to deal with the fact that some things remain hidden, but that’s often when faith and trust come in.  The Psalmist wrote:   “O Lord , my heart is not lifted up, my eyes are not raised too high; I do not occupy myself with things too great and too marvelous for me.”  (Ps 131:1) The Psalmist seem to realize that th...
Post a Comment
Read more